I’m going to let you in on a little secret about me: whining is my pet peeve. Probably more so than anything else. Whining seeps into my veins and yes, occasionally causes me to react rather than to just “act”. It is a weakness, but not one that can’t be developed into a strength.
It’s amazing. Since starting this series, my children have become more of a challenge. More whining taking place, more sibling rivalry. I thought it ironic. But then, I began to see what was happening. I’ve been spending more time on the computer. Hmmmm. Does this excuse the whining? Not exactly. However, the fault is really mine, because I have not been meeting their needs as much, therefore they are responding to that. When I say “needs” I mean need for attention. Not food and water. The point is, this very exercise proves how much our kids need us and “scream” for our attention. Is it an acceptable way to do it? No. But is it a legit need? Yes.
There are at least two types of whining that I am aware of. If there are more, I haven’t come across them [yet].
The first type is the when the child will speak in a whiny voice when asking for something. Sometimes this actually carries over into a child’s entire way of speaking if given into often enough. Friends, this is not something we want our children to grow up doing and live out as an adult. Think about it. Would you want your child to marry someone who is constantly whining? The whining changes slightly as an adult and turns into complaining or nagging. This is definitely something I do NOT want my daughter to marry into, nor do I want one of my sons to marry such a woman! If we don’t stop the whining, you can rest assured it WILL continue. This is not something that is outgrown. It is something we must correct.
The second type of whining that I am aware of is the kind that 2-and 3-year-olds typically do. I am training through the toddler years for the third time now, and every time I have dealt with the same whining. It’s the kind that is more crying-whining mixed together. The kind of whining that shows frustration and anger, but folks, it’s really annoying. Yes, much of it is due to the children’s age, BUT, that is not an excuse not to address, correct, and train our toddlers to know a better way. Much of the whining stems from a lack of communication skills.
Other reasons for this type of whining include being told “no” and not getting what they want, which requires immediate disciplinary attention.
There are several things to keep in mind when it comes to whining.
1. Find out the cause
Sometimes a child is whining because of unmet needs, just like the case of my children in response to spending more time on the computer. Thus, I can easily eliminate the whining by simply returning to meeting their needs.
Other needs could be discomfort, fatigue (which is a frequent case), break in routine, or life changes (new baby, moving, etc). This list is not exhaustive, but it does give you a clearer picture.
In cases like this, the first thing we need to do is meet the need. If the whining persists after the need is met, begin implementing discipline and/or training.
2. Train
The very first rule of whining is to never give in. This is training. Your children will learn that they will get nothing from whining. If you give in once, they will do it again until you break. Eventually they will understand again, but if they try to test you later, to see if you have that weakness, and you break, the cycle begins again. End the whiny talk and the whiny voice by ending the cycle. So no matter what, do not give in. The battle will be worth it, trust me!
It is wise for us to train our children before problems arise. The first thing we need to do is look in the mirror. Oh yes. Mothers, look in that mirror and look good. Do you see anything? Do your children see anything? Hmm…how about your husband? Sometimes our husbands are more apt to tell us than our children. Do you complain or nag….and do your children see? The first thing we must do is set good examples for our children to follow. If we are nagging our husbands and complaining at restuarants, our children pick up on this…especially if they see it working. Take some time to pray and clean out that closet. I know this is an area I need to check myself in minute by minute. This is also true of bad attitudes which we’ll get into tomorrow more.
A few ways to minimize the whining before addressing the discipline aspects would be:
- work on language skills through much reading and verbal language
- teach your child/baby simple sign language to help them communicate better with you
What are some other ways we can prevent whining before it starts?
We may not be able to stop 100% of the whining (especially in toddlers), but it can certainly be minimized.
3. Discipline
I want to give you a few examples on how you can discipline your child during whining episodes. Whatever you choose to use, stick with it.
If your child wakes up in the morning whining and generally has a bad attitude, put them back in their bed and explain to them they are not to come out until they are done whining. If they come out and continue to whine, take them back to bed and repeat the same thing, more briefly this time. Continue this exercise until your child comes out with a happy heart. (This works for me). Do it again the next day if you must. It should take about 3 days and your child should be as happy as sunshine in the morning! If need be, give them an earlier bed time and see if that does the trick; thirty minutes to an hour earlier and stick with it.
If your child asks you for something with a whiny tone, train them to ask you without whining before you will give them what they’re asking. After some time of training (3-7 days), if they still continue to whine when they initially ask you for something, do not give it to them. Tell them they know they are supposed to ask without whining and because they whined they do not get it. If we are talking about food or drink, make the answer “no”, but try to do it as a delay. For example, if your child is whining for something to drink, and you offer them water and they whine for juice, of course the answer is “no”. But if they then whine for water, tell them “no”, because they were whining and they now have to wait until snack time or dinner time (whatever meal is closest). Or specify an allotted amount of time. The point is, they are not getting what they wanted from whining. Even delaying it is not getting what they want. I would encourage you, though, only delay food and water. Make everything else a firm no, with no intentions of delay. The exception to this is if they come back to you later in the day and ask in the right manner, with no hint of whining. Then they may have what the seek, with your permission.
Make sure you visit Sarah Mae @ Like a Warm Cup of Coffee to learn more about whining. There is much to be said on the topic! In fact, there is so much to say, I am going to have to address “Bad Attitudes” tomorrow, in a post of it’s own!
I filled this one up addressing whining.
What are some specific whining challenges you’ve been dealing with?
Friday, I will post some Q&A’s so please post your challenges in this area!
If you haven’t yet, check out the giveaway! I’m giving away one copy of Say Goodbye to Whining, Complaining, and Bad Attitudes…in you and your Kids by Joanne Miller and Scott Turansky!
If you are new, check out these previous posts:
Training and Discipline Techniques for your Kiddos (A.K.A Civilizing Those Darn Sin Natures!) @ Like a Warm Cup of Coffee
Called to Discipline
Burdens or Blessings? No One Likes Being Around a Disobedient Child @ Like a Warm Cup of Coffee
Child Training and Discipline Require: Commitment and Consistency
How Do I View My Children As Blessings in the “Everyday”? @ At the Well
Excellent Resources
Biblical Parenting
Raising Godly Tomatoes
No Greater Joy